How to learn who reads my blog?
Thoughts on diesel/petrol mix
Hello Guest
  
  • Login
• Register…
• Start blog
  • Who, Where, When
• What is interesting here?
• Duels
  • Polls
• Avatars
• Interests
  • Cities and Countries
• Random blog
• Users search
  • Search
• Games
• Tests
• CarGuru
  • Ñîîáùåñòâà
• Talxy Chat
• Horoscope
• Online
 
Register!

CarGuru > Open discussion > Thoughts on diesel/petrol mix 18 April 2005 13:42:40

  Recent blog posts: 
  They have birthday today: 
  Forums:   
  Discuss: 
  Recent forum topics: 
  Recent forum comments:
  Ìîäåðàòîð:

Thoughts on diesel/petrol mix

Andrew Carr 11 April 2005 01:43:54
 While filing my ten year old ford escort van with diesel this morning I was
looking at the price of petrol.

I got thinking about a 90% diesel 10% petrol mix similar to what is
suggested in the handbook for winter use.

Taking in mind that this would increase the calorific content of the fuel,
what would you opinion on using a mix of this for a prolonged length of
time.

I was thinking of a slight increase in engine wear (not a great concern with
a ten year old rusty vehicle) against a small increase in power and fuel
saving being able to go up the gears more quickly.




Add comment
Duncan Wood 11 April 2005 02:00:26 permanent link ]
 On Sun, 10 Apr 2005 22:43:54 +0100, Andrew Carr
<zymurgist@nettaxi.­com.net> wrote:
While filing my ten year old ford escort van with diesel this morning I > was> looking at the price of petrol.>
I got thinking about a 90% diesel 10% petrol mix similar to what is> suggested in the handbook for winter use.>
Taking in mind that this would increase the calorific content of the > fuel,> what would you opinion on using a mix of this for a prolonged length of> time.>
I was thinking of a slight increase in engine wear (not a great concern > with> a ten year old rusty vehicle) against a small increase in power and fuel> saving being able to go up the gears more quickly.>

As it'll drop the viscosity of the mixture you'll get less fuel injected ,
which'll more than overcompensate for the negligible change in calorific
content.
Add comment
Moray Cuthill 11 April 2005 02:16:10 permanent link ]
 "Andrew Carr" <zymurgist@nettaxi.­com.net> wrote in message
news:45CdnQYALd6HA8­TfRVnygw@pipex.net..­.> While filing my ten year old ford escort van with diesel this morning I > was> looking at the price of petrol.>
I got thinking about a 90% diesel 10% petrol mix similar to what is> suggested in the handbook for winter use.>
Taking in mind that this would increase the calorific content of the fuel,> what would you opinion on using a mix of this for a prolonged length of> time.

Diesel has the higher calorifc value, so mixing petrol in will reduce it.
As for using it over a longer period of time, it'll increase wear on the
fuel injection components, and also on the upper cylinder components.
I was thinking of a slight increase in engine wear (not a great concern > with> a ten year old rusty vehicle) against a small increase in power and fuel> saving being able to go up the gears more quickly.

If anything, it'll reduce performance, and besides it's an escort van. It
takes a lot more than a change off fuel to get them to move any quicker.


Add comment
Shazzbat 11 April 2005 12:11:14 permanent link ]
 
"Duncan Wood" <spam@dmx512.co.uk>­ wrote in message
news:opso1d12kcpjbt­ie@amy...> On Sun, 10 Apr 2005 22:43:54 +0100, Andrew Carr> <zymurgist@nettaxi.­com.net> wrote:>
While filing my ten year old ford escort van with diesel this morning I> > was> > looking at the price of petrol.> >
I got thinking about a 90% diesel 10% petrol mix similar to what is> > suggested in the handbook for winter use.> >
Taking in mind that this would increase the calorific content of the> > fuel,> > what would you opinion on using a mix of this for a prolonged length of> > time.> >
I was thinking of a slight increase in engine wear (not a great concern> > with> > a ten year old rusty vehicle) against a small increase in power and fuel> > saving being able to go up the gears more quickly.> >
As it'll drop the viscosity of the mixture you'll get less fuel injected ,> which'll more than overcompensate for the negligible change in calorific> content.

No. It's injected by volume. The same volume will be injected whether it's
diesel or a mixture of fuels and the petrol will be ignited along with the
diesel, so nop problem.

But as to the OP's question, I say go for it if you have it, especially for
an old banger. Whenever I have been called out to people who have filled at
the wrong pump, I have always put the mixed fuel in my old banger of a truck
if it's mostly diesel, or in my daughters old banger cars if it's mostly
petrol. Although if I'm at all iffy about it I don't put it all in in one
go.

It's yet another good reason for driving old bangers, you can get away with
far more than newer vehicles.

Steve


Add comment
Petermcmillan Uk 11 April 2005 14:15:54 permanent link ]
 
Andrew Carr wrote:> While filing my ten year old ford escort van with diesel this morning
I was> looking at the price of petrol.>
I got thinking about a 90% diesel 10% petrol mix similar to what is> suggested in the handbook for winter use.>
Taking in mind that this would increase the calorific content of the
fuel,> what would you opinion on using a mix of this for a prolonged length
time.>
I was thinking of a slight increase in engine wear (not a great
concern with> a ten year old rusty vehicle) against a small increase in power and
fuel> saving being able to go up the gears more quickly.

Is it worth bothering for the price difference? It's only going to be
a real benefit if you do really high mileage. Correct me if I'm wrong,
but IIRC there is only around 10p/litre difference, so you'd be looking
at about 50p saving per 50l, and that's probably more than a tank full.
So what's that gonna be? Around 1p saving for every 10 miles (very
approx guessing mpg etc)?

Add comment
Guy King 11 April 2005 15:34:52 permanent link ]
 The message <opso1d12kcpjbtie@a­my>
from "Duncan Wood" <spam@dmx512.co.uk>­ contains these words:
As it'll drop the viscosity of the mixture you'll get less fuel injected , > which'll more than overcompensate for the negligible change in calorific > content.

Really? I'd have thought the runnier the fuel the more easily it'd get
through the holes. But even then only to the extent that the injector
pipes are springy 'cos it's forced in by the pistons in the injector
pump. It's not like petrol injection where the amount is controlled by
time from the high pressure rail.

--
Skipweasel.
In the beginning was the word.
And the word was Aardvark.
Add comment
Tollermccallum 11 April 2005 23:43:28 permanent link ]
 
Is it worth bothering for the price difference? It's only going to be> a real benefit if you do really high mileage. Correct me if I'm wrong,> but IIRC there is only around 10p/litre difference, so you'd be looking> at about 50p saving per 50l, and that's probably more than a tank full.> So what's that gonna be? Around 1p saving for every 10 miles (very> approx guessing mpg etc)?

I have a friend who has been running his 2.0 diesel vectra on
vegetable oil for some time, costs him about 25p a litre only problem
being it smells like he's pulling a chip shop behind him.

Even though it's illegal he knows of quite a few other people who are
doing it including one particular 4x4 owner who took his for it's MOT
with half a tank of veg oil in it, and it passed :)­

May be worth considering if the fuel prices keep going up the way they
have been, just don't let Mr customs and excise catch you.
Add comment
Duncan Wood 12 April 2005 00:45:02 permanent link ]
 Guy King <guy.king@zetnet.co­.uk> wrote in message news:<3130303034323­739425A6EEC44@zetnet­.co.uk>...> The message <opso1d12kcpjbtie@a­my>> from "Duncan Wood" <spam@dmx512.co.uk>­ contains these words:>
As it'll drop the viscosity of the mixture you'll get less fuel injected , > > which'll more than overcompensate for the negligible change in calorific > > content.>
Really? I'd have thought the runnier the fuel the more easily it'd get> through the holes. But even then only to the extent that the injector> pipes are springy 'cos it's forced in by the pistons in the injector> pump. It's not like petrol injection where the amount is controlled by> time from the high pressure rail.

What stuffs you is the transfer pressure in the pump (which determines
how much fuel can get in between the pistons before they're pushed
together) drops & the leakage past said pistons increases, it can be
significant with temperature so some commercial plant pumps with
hitorque rise characteristics have secondary viscosity compensation
systems.
Add comment
Stuffed 12 April 2005 01:34:52 permanent link ]
 
"tollermccallum" <kris.hallas@virgin­.net> wrote in message
news:b85164d4.05041­11143.433ca037@posti­ng.google.com...
I have a friend who has been running his 2.0 diesel vectra on> vegetable oil for some time, costs him about 25p a litre only problem> being it smells like he's pulling a chip shop behind him.>
Even though it's illegal he knows of quite a few other people who are> doing it including one particular 4x4 owner who took his for it's MOT> with half a tank of veg oil in it, and it passed :)­>
May be worth considering if the fuel prices keep going up the way they> have been, just don't let Mr customs and excise catch you.

I thought it was perfectly legal so long as you declare it and pay the
relevent duty.

Of course, you might be slightly absent minded when topping up once in a
while though...


Add comment
Petermcmillan Uk 12 April 2005 13:10:11 permanent link ]
 
Stuffed wrote:> "tollermccallum" <kris.hallas@virgin­.net> wrote in message> news:b85164d4.05041­11143.433ca037@posti­ng.google.com...>
I have a friend who has been running his 2.0 diesel vectra on> > vegetable oil for some time, costs him about 25p a litre only
problem> > being it smells like he's pulling a chip shop behind him.> >
Even though it's illegal he knows of quite a few other people who
doing it including one particular 4x4 owner who took his for it's
with half a tank of veg oil in it, and it passed :)­> >
May be worth considering if the fuel prices keep going up the way
they> > have been, just don't let Mr customs and excise catch you.>
I thought it was perfectly legal so long as you declare it and pay
relevent duty.>
Of course, you might be slightly absent minded when topping up once
in a> while though...

Yeah, the problem is that the tax costs a LOT more than the veg oil.
To be honest, I don't think it's really worth using new vegy oil, and
paying tax because you'll probably only save a few pence if you're
lucky. Of course, if you can get used vegy oil really cheaply then you
could make a nice saving.

Add comment
Andrew Carr 12 April 2005 20:15:28 permanent link ]
 veggie oil is out, a neighbour works for customs and excise and take great
pleasure in dropping people in it.


<petermcmillan_uk@y­ahoo.com> wrote in message
news:1113297011.183­587.184080@g14g2000c­wa.googlegroups.com.­..>
Stuffed wrote:> > "tollermccallum" <kris.hallas@virgin­.net> wrote in message> > news:b85164d4.05041­11143.433ca037@posti­ng.google.com...> >
I have a friend who has been running his 2.0 diesel vectra on> > > vegetable oil for some time, costs him about 25p a litre only> problem> > > being it smells like he's pulling a chip shop behind him.> > >
Even though it's illegal he knows of quite a few other people who> are> > > doing it including one particular 4x4 owner who took his for it's> MOT> > > with half a tank of veg oil in it, and it passed :)­> > >
May be worth considering if the fuel prices keep going up the way> they> > > have been, just don't let Mr customs and excise catch you.> >
I thought it was perfectly legal so long as you declare it and pay> the> > relevent duty.> >
Of course, you might be slightly absent minded when topping up once> in a> > while though...>
Yeah, the problem is that the tax costs a LOT more than the veg oil.> To be honest, I don't think it's really worth using new vegy oil, and> paying tax because you'll probably only save a few pence if you're> lucky. Of course, if you can get used vegy oil really cheaply then you> could make a nice saving.>


Add comment
Grimly Curmudgeon 13 April 2005 02:28:05 permanent link ]
 It was somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the
drugs began to take hold. I remember kris.hallas@virgin.­net
(tollermccallum) saying something like:
I have a friend who has been running his 2.0 diesel vectra on>vegetable oil for some time, costs him about 25p a litre only problem>being it smells like he's pulling a chip shop behind him.>
Even though it's illegal

It's not illegal if you tell C&E and pay the 20p or so duty on it. Just
tell your friend to make sure he has a receipt for it in the car.
--

Dave
SE6a
Add comment
Grimly Curmudgeon 13 April 2005 04:06:39 permanent link ]
 It was somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the
drugs began to take hold. I remember Chris Street
<venus.ngfb@chris-s­treet.demon.co.uk> saying something like:
You cannot use just vegetable oil - there are a lot of things in there that>do a good job of gumming up the works.

In a properly designed heated system it works fine and problems are
avoided. The trick is to start and stop on fuel oil, thereby flushing
the pump and injectors with diesel before shutdown.
--

Dave
SE6a
Add comment
Chris Street 13 April 2005 04:56:22 permanent link ]
 On Wed, 13 Apr 2005 01:06:39 +0100, Grimly Curmudgeon wrote:
It was somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the> drugs began to take hold. I remember Chris Street> <venus.ngfb@chris-s­treet.demon.co.uk> saying something like:>
You cannot use just vegetable oil - there are a lot of things in there that>>do a good job of gumming up the works.>
In a properly designed heated system it works fine and problems are> avoided. The trick is to start and stop on fuel oil, thereby flushing> the pump and injectors with diesel before shutdown.

Well yes but like I said - not just vegetable oil.
Add comment
Delgardo 13 April 2005 14:59:17 permanent link ]
 
"Chris Street" <venus.ngfb@chris-s­treet.demon.co.uk> wrote in message
news:10ena3268mfoo$­.13o98gq2mk6e7$.dlg@­40tude.net...> On Wed, 13 Apr 2005 01:06:39 +0100, Grimly Curmudgeon wrote:>
It was somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the> > drugs began to take hold. I remember Chris Street> > <venus.ngfb@chris-s­treet.demon.co.uk> saying something like:> >
You cannot use just vegetable oil - there are a lot of things in there
that> >>do a good job of gumming up the works.> >
In a properly designed heated system it works fine and problems are> > avoided. The trick is to start and stop on fuel oil, thereby flushing> > the pump and injectors with diesel before shutdown.>
Well yes but like I said - not just vegetable oil.


I ran a Rover 620 on just Vegtable oil for probably more than 2000 miles.
Initally I used to mix it with white spirt (as a lot of sources had
recomended) in a 10 to 1 blend, but then I just didn't bother with that in
the end.

Only problems I had were in cold weather. It became slightly harder to start
(even then I still rarly needed the glow plugs) and it would sometimes stall
easily for the first couple of minutes until it warmed up. The L-series was
always a good starter I'll conceed though.

As far as I can tell it caused no damage and ran just as it had when I stuck
derv back in it. I'll agree that it's probably not the most conclusive test
for running a car on veg oil long term.


Add comment
Nik&Andy 17 April 2005 23:03:53 permanent link ]
 
"Delgardo" <nobody@nobody.com>­ wrote in message
news:ERCM293265D9BC­@eurocom.com...>
"Chris Street" <venus.ngfb@chris-s­treet.demon.co.uk> wrote in message> news:10ena3268mfoo$­.13o98gq2mk6e7$.dlg@­40tude.net...>> On Wed, 13 Apr 2005 01:06:39 +0100, Grimly Curmudgeon wrote:>>
It was somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the>> > drugs began to take hold. I remember Chris Street>> > <venus.ngfb@chris-s­treet.demon.co.uk> saying something like:>> >
You cannot use just vegetable oil - there are a lot of things in there> that>> >>do a good job of gumming up the works.>> >
In a properly designed heated system it works fine and problems are>> > avoided. The trick is to start and stop on fuel oil, thereby flushing>> > the pump and injectors with diesel before shutdown.>>
Well yes but like I said - not just vegetable oil.>
I ran a Rover 620 on just Vegtable oil for probably more than 2000 miles.> Initally I used to mix it with white spirt (as a lot of sources had> recomended) in a 10 to 1 blend, but then I just didn't bother with that in> the end.>
Only problems I had were in cold weather. It became slightly harder to > start> (even then I still rarly needed the glow plugs) and it would sometimes > stall> easily for the first couple of minutes until it warmed up. The L-series > was> always a good starter I'll conceed though.>
As far as I can tell it caused no damage and ran just as it had when I > stuck> derv back in it. I'll agree that it's probably not the most conclusive > test> for running a car on veg oil long term.>
Wasn't that a Peugeot XU series engine??

Andy


Add comment
Delgardo 18 April 2005 13:42:40 permanent link ]
 
"Nik&Andy" <nicola@adenleyremo­vethis.f9.co.uk> wrote in message
news:4262b31b$0$422­91$ed2619ec@ptn-nntp­-reader02.plus.net..­.>
"Delgardo" <nobody@nobody.com>­ wrote in message> news:ERCM293265D9BC­@eurocom.com...> >
"Chris Street" <venus.ngfb@chris-s­treet.demon.co.uk> wrote in message> > news:10ena3268mfoo$­.13o98gq2mk6e7$.dlg@­40tude.net...> >> On Wed, 13 Apr 2005 01:06:39 +0100, Grimly Curmudgeon wrote:> >>
It was somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the> >> > drugs began to take hold. I remember Chris Street> >> > <venus.ngfb@chris-s­treet.demon.co.uk> saying something like:> >> >
You cannot use just vegetable oil - there are a lot of things in
there> > that> >> >>do a good job of gumming up the works.> >> >
In a properly designed heated system it works fine and problems are> >> > avoided. The trick is to start and stop on fuel oil, thereby flushing> >> > the pump and injectors with diesel before shutdown.> >>
Well yes but like I said - not just vegetable oil.> >
I ran a Rover 620 on just Vegtable oil for probably more than 2000
miles.> > Initally I used to mix it with white spirt (as a lot of sources had> > recomended) in a 10 to 1 blend, but then I just didn't bother with that
the end.> >
Only problems I had were in cold weather. It became slightly harder to> > start> > (even then I still rarly needed the glow plugs) and it would sometimes> > stall> > easily for the first couple of minutes until it warmed up. The L-series> > was> > always a good starter I'll conceed though.> >
As far as I can tell it caused no damage and ran just as it had when I> > stuck> > derv back in it. I'll agree that it's probably not the most conclusive> > test> > for running a car on veg oil long term.> >
Wasn't that a Peugeot XU series engine??>
Andy>

Nope, that was the 1.8 lump Rover used in the 200/400 series. The 2.0 as
used in the 600, "bubble shaped" 200 and early 75s was their own.


Add comment
 

Add new comment

As:
Login:  Password:  
 
 
  
 
respect your talk pals, avoid using obscene language, typing entire messages in CAPS, posting buy/sell ads or violating netiquette or the RF Criminal Code..


CarGuru > Open discussion > Thoughts on diesel/petrol mix 18 April 2005 13:42:40

see also:
US 40 - Maryland - Jug Bridge Memorial…
Illinois 2007-2012 Highway Improvement…
Re: In Union there's Strength
pass tests:
{censored}
see also:
xaxaxa ug ne projdet!!!

  Copyright © 2001—2009 Car-Guru
Idea: Miñhael Monashev
See Help and FAQ in the community support.car-guru.com.
Write in the community about the bugs you have noticedbugs.car-guru.com.
Write your offers and comments in the communities suggest.car-guru.com.
Information for parents.
Write us at:
If you would like to report an abuse of our service, such as a spam message, please .